If you know the Catholic devotion to the Sacred Heart of Jesus, you’ll know that it has some of the most tasteful and powerful images. The sort of images that inspire the soul, transcend cultural contexts, and are not in least bit kitschy.
Actually, if you know the Sacred Heart, you know that some of the iconography is awful. Seriously awful. There are genuinely some shockers out there. Shall we take a quick tour?
I mean, there’s Too Much Rogue Jesus.
And his cousin, Went Overboard With The Eyeliner Jesus. (Ocassionally known as Forked Beard Jesus.)
Then there’s Sucking On A Lemon Jesus.
A more modern take with Come At Me Bro Jesus.
And my personal favourite, Superman Jesus. (With complimentary spiral beard.)
Of course, making fun of some of the Sacred Heart imagery is way too easy. It’s not entirely fair, either. These are pictures beloved by generations, and they spoke to a different time. In many ways, a much more innocent time, a gentler time, a time when saccharine moralising was the coolest thing around…
(Ok, but we can hardly point fingers either, because have you seen the sort of “inspirational” calendars, bookmarks and figurines sold in your average Christian store? Yeah… Not much to be proud of there.)
These are particularly bad ones, but even the better ones aren’t that great. I think the problem is that, quite unintentionally, they diminish the sufferings of Our Lord.
1. Pretty Jesus?
Have you have stuck a spear in a dead man’s side? No? Me neither, but I’ve seen enough Game of Thrones to know that it is not a pretty sight.
In fact, nothing about the Crucifixion of Our Lord was pretty. It was ugly, and bloody, and cruel. When Jesus looks too pretty, His sufferings lose their impact because we all know that no one with such neatly parted, glossy hair could be in that much distress.
Isaiah tells us that the Suffering Messiah “had no form or comeliness that we should look at him, and no beauty that we should desire him.” (Isa 53:3)
The Sacred Heart should reveal to us the horror of the Crucifixion, and of all that Christ endured for love of us. Pretty Jesus doesn’t do that.
2. Passive Jesus?
In all of these pictures, Christ seems so passive. And by passive, I mean it in the perjorative sense of lifeless and idle. But Christ is anything but. There is definitely a stillness to the Sacred Heart, which has “never ceased, and never will cease, to beat with calm and imperturable pulsations.” (Haurietis Aquas, 61) But it is a divine stillness, that sums up all that has been, and is, and will ever be, in one infinite moment.
To be fair, that’s very hard to depict. And so we have images where this stillness becomes passivity, which so easily slips into insipidity.
The Sacred Heart should show us how Christ actively laid down His life, and all the love, and passion, and human struggle that that took. Passive Jesus doesn’t do that.
3. Pastiche Jesus?
Pastiche can be fun, but not when you take it so literally. These Sacred Heart images do. They literally just paste a heart on Jesus’ chest and call it a day. This just weirds me out. On the one hand, the pictures are very naturalistic. On the other, there’s a symbol of a heart floating in the middle of His Body.
And somehow, it lessens the power of the image. Please, just pick one. Either go naturalistic or iconographic because when you try to do both, you end up with neither. Instead, you end up with a “realistic” picture of Jesus which doesn’t seem human, or a “symbolic” icon of Christ which seems too naturalistic to do the job properly.
The Sacred Heart should pull us into the Passion of Christ so that we lose sight of the physical art. Pastiche Jesus doesn’t do that.
The Sacred Heart isn’t about some pretty, passive Jesus with doleful eyes, immaculate hair, and a heart stuck on His front. It is the symbol of the love of our Redeemer, a love with “neither death, nor life, nor angels, nor principalities, nor things present, nor things to come, nor powers, nor height, nor depth, nor anything else in all creation” can overcome. (Rom 8:36) Because Divine Love, taking flesh and a human heart, has overcome the world.
Do you know any good pictures of the Sacred Heart? Please link below! I’d like to make a collection of Pictures Of The Sacred Heart That Don’t Make Me Cringe.